Re: [PATCH v6 09/12] x86/mm: enable broadcast TLB invalidation for multi-threaded processes

[Rik van Riel <riel@surriel.com>]

On Mon, 2025-01-20 at 22:04 +0200, Nadav Amit wrote:
> 
> What about this scenario for instance?
> 
> CPU0                  CPU1                      CPU2
> ----                  ----                      ----
> (1) use_global_asid(mm):        
>     mm->context.asid_trans = T;
>     mm->context.global_asid = G;
> 
>                       (2) switch_mm(..., next=mm):
>                           *Observes global_asid = G
>                           => loads CR3 with PCID=G
>                           => fills TLB under G.
>                           TLB caches PTE[G, V] = P
> 			  (for some reason)
> 
>                                              (3)
> flush_tlb_mm_range(mm):
>                                                  *Sees global_asid ==
> 0
>                                                    (stale/old value)
>                                                  => flush_tlb_multi()
>                                                  => IPI flush for
> dyn.
> 

If the TLB flush is about a page table change that
happened before CPUs 0 and 1 switched to the global
ASID, then CPUs 0 and 1 will not see the old page
table contents after the switch.

If the TLB flush is about a page table change that
happened after the transition to a global ASID,
flush_tlb_mm_range() should see that global ASID,
and flush accordingly.

What am I missing?

>                       (4) IPI arrives on CPU1:
>                           flush_tlb_func(...): 
>                           is_global_asid(G)? yes,
>                           skip invalidate; broadcast
>                           flush assumed to cover it.
> 
>                                              (5) IPI completes on
> CPU2:
>                                                  Dyn. ASIDs are
> flushed, 
>                                                  but CPU1’s global
> ASID
>                                                  was never
> invalidated!
> 
>                       (6) CPU1 uses stale TLB entries under ASID G.
>                           TLB continues to use PTE[G, V] = P, as it
>                           was not invalidated.
> 
> 
> 
> 
> 

-- 
All Rights Reversed.