From mboxrd@z Thu Jan 1 00:00:00 1970 Return-Path: Received: from mail143.messagelabs.com (mail143.messagelabs.com [216.82.254.35]) by kanga.kvack.org (Postfix) with SMTP id 082C86B004F for ; Mon, 17 Aug 2009 15:47:33 -0400 (EDT) From: "Dike, Jeffrey G" Date: Mon, 17 Aug 2009 12:47:29 -0700 Subject: RE: [RFC] respect the referenced bit of KVM guest pages? Message-ID: <9EECC02A4CC333418C00A85D21E89326B6611F25@azsmsx502.amr.corp.intel.com> References: <20090805155805.GC23385@random.random> <20090806100824.GO23385@random.random> <4A7AAE07.1010202@redhat.com> <20090806102057.GQ23385@random.random> <20090806105932.GA1569@localhost> <4A7AC201.4010202@redhat.com> <20090806130631.GB6162@localhost> <4A7AD79E.4020604@redhat.com> <20090816032822.GB6888@localhost> <4A878377.70502@redhat.com> <20090816045522.GA13740@localhost> In-Reply-To: <20090816045522.GA13740@localhost> Content-Language: en-US Content-Type: text/plain; charset="us-ascii" Content-Transfer-Encoding: quoted-printable MIME-Version: 1.0 Sender: owner-linux-mm@kvack.org To: "Wu, Fengguang" , Rik van Riel Cc: Avi Kivity , Andrea Arcangeli , "Yu, Wilfred" , "Kleen, Andi" , Hugh Dickins , Andrew Morton , Christoph Lameter , KOSAKI Motohiro , Mel Gorman , LKML , linux-mm List-ID: > Jeff, can you have a look at these stats? Thanks! Yeah, I just did after adding some tracing which dumped out the same data. = It looks pretty much the same. Inactive anon and active anon are pretty s= imilar. Inactive file and active file are smaller and fluctuate more, but = doesn't look horribly unbalanced. Below are the stats from memory.stat - inactive_anon, active_anon, inactive= _file, active_file, plus some commentary on what's happening. Jeff 114688 0 1978368 630784 114688 0 1978368 630784 114688 0 1978368 630784 114688 0 1978368 630784 114688 0 1978368 630784 114688 0 1978368 630784 114688 0 1978368 630784 # Fire up instance 20480 4403200 2699264 647168 20480 4411392 2740224 647168 20480 4411392 2740224 647168 20480 11436032 3289088 651264 20480 11587584 3313664 651264 20480 12558336 3313664 651264 20480 12558336 3313664 651264 20480 12558336 3313664 651264 20480 12558336 3313664 651264 20480 12558336 3313664 651264 20480 12558336 3313664 651264 20480 12558336 3313664 651264 20480 12558336 3313664 651264 20480 25387008 4263936 872448 20480 25387008 4263936 872448 20480 25387008 4198400 937984 20480 25387008 4198400 937984 20480 25387008 4198400 937984 20480 25387008 4198400 937984 20480 25387008 4198400 937984 20480 25387008 4198400 937984 20480 25387008 4198400 937984 20480 25387008 4198400 937984 20480 25411584 4198400 937984 20480 25411584 4198400 937984 20480 40665088 7573504 946176 20480 43606016 7573504 946176 20480 45346816 7581696 946176 20480 45752320 7581696 946176 20480 46575616 7581696 946176 20480 46682112 7581696 946176 20480 48975872 9920512 1073152 20480 64536576 38457344 1826816 # Booted, X is starting # Run a browser and editor, then shut them down and halt the instance 10964992 72454144 47714304 3067904 16797696 71151616 42893312 3244032 16797696 73035776 41037824 3272704 16797696 73547776 40525824 3272704 16797696 73609216 40402944 3276800 16797696 73719808 40337408 3289088 16797696 73920512 40079360 3289088 16797696 78016512 36036608 3297280 16797696 78016512 36036608 3297280 16797696 80203776 33755136 3387392 16797696 86904832 26972160 3526656 16797696 93523968 19927040 3837952 29011968 90546176 10276864 4308992 45670400 83685376 991232 3854336 66400256 66416640 368640 933888 66715648 66654208 376832 471040 64811008 64802816 3416064 1114112 65236992 65085440 2535424 1228800 65212416 65011712 2519040 1343488 64626688 64610304 3534848 1429504 63807488 63758336 4829184 1695744 63975424 63946752 4419584 1744896 63975424 63946752 4419584 1744896 63975424 63946752 4419584 1744896 63975424 63946752 4423680 1744896 63975424 63946752 4423680 1744896 63975424 63946752 4423680 1744896 64045056 63946752 4440064 1757184 64069632 63946752 4440064 1757184 64077824 63946752 4403200 1757184 64077824 63946752 4403200 1757184 64077824 63946752 4403200 1757184 64147456 64016384 4222976 1757184 64638976 64733184 2801664 1900544 65208320 65605632 1310720 1892352 64946176 65863680 1335296 1998848 62701568 68599808 843776 1945600 66068480 66023424 778240 978944 65568768 65511424 2093056 1044480 66183168 66056192 966656 1011712 66478080 66555904 241664 864256 66912256 66899968 135168 270336 66646016 66539520 577536 262144 66134016 66179072 1421312 319488 66125824 66183168 1273856 380928 66330624 66445312 933888 475136 65970176 65966080 1581056 548864 66158592 66158592 1175552 708608 65781760 66084864 1503232 806912 66084864 66048000 1118208 843776 66420736 66449408 376832 851968 66351104 66138112 757760 864256 66285568 66138112 921600 868352 65945600 65847296 1495040 888832 66002944 65839104 1363968 888832 66002944 65839104 1363968 888832 66039808 65839104 1363968 888832 66043904 65839104 1363968 888832 66043904 65839104 1372160 888832 65523712 65490944 2224128 929792 66031616 66297856 827392 946176 64913408 68141056 188416 933888 64770048 68325376 73728 917504 65216512 67932160 81920 909312 65470464 67678208 81920 909312 65036288 67973120 356352 790528 63492096 69877760 110592 647168 63111168 70508544 73728 413696 66895872 66883584 16384 348160 66650112 67203072 20480 344064 66830336 67002368 28672 335872 66785280 67002368 32768 331776 67084288 66736128 45056 331776 67104768 66736128 45056 331776 66916352 66801664 45056 331776 66883584 66863104 45056 331776 66883584 66863104 45056 331776 66891776 66863104 45056 331776 66899968 66863104 45056 331776 66904064 66863104 45056 331776 66904064 66863104 45056 331776 66904064 66863104 45056 331776 66715648 66641920 385024 339968 66617344 66629632 237568 364544 66633728 66629632 237568 364544 66641920 66629632 237568 364544 66641920 66629632 237568 364544 66662400 66461696 589824 389120 66588672 66527232 659456 389120 66252800 66252800 1105920 413696 66277376 66297856 983040 413696 66498560 66285568 884736 413696 66129920 66183168 1163264 442368 66138112 66183168 1163264 442368 66256896 66465792 921600 442368 66560000 66465792 606208 442368 66662400 66445312 589824 446464 66560000 66490368 708608 446464 66629632 66441216 577536 446464 66711552 66441216 520192 462848 66617344 66531328 577536 466944 66412544 66605056 606208 466944 66605056 66637824 475136 471040 66297856 67018752 344064 483328 65863680 67588096 212992 483328 66334720 67129344 159744 516096 65204224 68337664 159744 516096 61399040 72212480 98304 499712 62427136 71114752 98304 499712 62775296 70680576 155648 503808 62595072 70209536 823296 565248 66490368 66576384 458752 577536 66818048 66625536 196608 577536 66699264 66793472 135168 507904 66707456 66736128 151552 512000 66314240 67293184 53248 483328 56832000 76705792 180224 495616 59273216 73998336 368640 499712 59351040 73928704 368640 499712 59400192 73928704 368640 499712 59678720 73478144 241664 495616 59875328 73531392 241664 495616 60690432 72830976 110592 503808 61919232 71634944 110592 503808 65523712 68096000 49152 483328 66748416 66801664 102400 487424 65994752 67555328 114688 487424 65994752 67555328 114688 487424 65994752 67555328 114688 487424 66285568 66195456 1093632 520192 66232320 65978368 1335296 557056 66232320 65978368 1335296 557056 66232320 65978368 1335296 557056 66232320 65978368 1335296 557056 66060288 65994752 1548288 557056 # Instance halted 118784 0 1953792 569344 118784 0 1953792 569344 118784 0 1953792 569344 118784 0 1953792 569344 118784 0 1953792 569344 118784 0 1953792 569344 118784 0 1953792 569344 118784 0 1953792 569344 -- To unsubscribe, send a message with 'unsubscribe linux-mm' in the body to majordomo@kvack.org. For more info on Linux MM, see: http://www.linux-mm.org/ . Don't email: email@kvack.org