Re: [PATCH] mm/vmscan: restore zone_reclaim_mode ABI

[Dave Hansen <dave.hansen@intel.com>]

On 6/28/20 11:52 PM, Baoquan He wrote:
> On 06/25/20 at 05:34pm, Dave Hansen wrote:
>>
>> From: Dave Hansen <dave.hansen@linux.intel.com>
>>
>> I went to go add a new RECLAIM_* mode for the zone_reclaim_mode
>> sysctl.  Like a good kernel developer, I also went to go update the
>> documentation.  I noticed that the bits in the documentation didn't
>> match the bits in the #defines.
>>
>> The VM evidently stopped caring about RECLAIM_ZONE at some point (or
>> never cared) and the #define itself was later removed as a cleanup.
> 
>>From git history, it seems to never care about the RECLAIM_ZONE bit.
> 
> I think this patch is justified. I have one question about adding back
> the RECLAIM_ZONE bit. Since we introduced RECLAIM_ZONE in the first
> place, but never use it, removing it truly may fail some existing
> script, does it mean we will never have chance to fix/clean up this kind
> of mess?

Our #1 rule is "don't break userspace".  We only break userspace when we
have no other choice.

This case a bit fuzzier because we don't know if anyone is depending on
the ignored bit to do anything.  But, it *was* documented.  To me, that
means it might have been used, even though it would have been a
"placebo" bit.

> Do we have possibility to remove it in mainline tree, let distos or
> stable kernel maintainer take care of the back porting? Like this, any
> stable kernel after 5.8, or any distrols which chooses post v5.8 kenrel
> as base won't have this confusion. I am not objecting this patch, just
> be curious if we have a way to fix/clean up for this type of issue.

The only way I can plausibly think of "cleaning up" the RECLAIM_ZONE bit
would be to raise our confidence that it is truly unused.  That takes
time, and probably a warning if we see it being set.  If we don't run
into anybody setting it or depending on it being set in a few years, we
can remove it.

Backporting a _warning_ into the -stable trees might be an interesting
way to find users of older kernels mucking with it.