Hi Linus, > This wasn't even remotely a gray area. It's not worth discussing. I hope you understood that my wish for transparency was not about discussing if the patches should have gone in or not. It is about discussing or at least stating which reasons we have for not accepting patches. From the netdev maintainers reply, I couldn't understand if being "uncomfortable" was because of personal or juristic reasons. As a result, I was unsure what to do if such patches would have landed in my subsystem. If it was personal, then I may or may not have a different opinion, OK. If it was jurisitc, then it might be wise to follow their expertise. Of course, I could have asked the netdev maintainers. But if it is written right away, it makes things easier, or so I thought... Regards, Wolfram